Sunday, April 19, 2009

Corruption and Greed: The Cultural Manyatta Story

Helloo!! So I know that I said I was going to post the day after my Nakuru post, but one thing leads to another and….(I’m on Africa time remember). I cannot believe where the time has gone, 2 ½ weeks until my program ends and 4 weeks until I’m home. It seemed like yesterday that I got here, and also seems like I’ve lived here forever. I could honestly stay in Kenya forever, but I am getting very stir-crazy at camp and am ready to get home to see all of you!!! Ideally, I would like to move all of my loved ones to Kenya, and have the best of both worlds…any takers? So here is my update for the past week and a half.

We’re in the last third of my program which focuses on directed research. We’ve split into three groups, have each been assigned a professor, and are working on different research subjects. Okello, my wildlife management professor, is mapping the wildlife and human settlements within the group ranches surrounding Amboseli National Park. It is working to show the amount of human encroachment on wildlife corridors, and hopefully propose some ideas to prevent this in the future. Kiringe, my wildlife ecology professor, is looking at the condition of rangelands, determining how increased human populations have aided in their deterioration. Although these are both very exciting, I couldn’t turn down Tome’s, my environmental policy professor, when I heard about his.

We have spent the past 8 days “assessing cultural manyattas as a means of capitalizing on conservation benefits in the Amboseli region, Kenya: economic, social and environmental implications” (good thing I had my proposal title handy haha). I LOVE it since it is all about the people. Cultural manyattas is a form of cultural tourism that stemmed from community conservation. Community conservation is an initiative that helps form the relationship between biodiversity conservation and development of rural communities. It has been manifested globally in many forms, such as the development of national parks, whose revenue can be given back to the local people. However, this revenue is often too little to remove the people from poverty; therefore, cultural tourism has become increasingly popular as a way for people to get direct revenue from tourism. Cultural tourism is a form of community conservation since they congregate around regions that have an existing tourist population from wildlife. Cultural manyattas are an example of cultural tourism within the Maasailand of Kenya (where my school is located). They are large bomas of Maasai people, who teach tourists about their culture through lectures on ceremonies and gender roles, also showing them dances, traditional medicine and ways of making fire. Each tourist must pay an entrance fee of $20 USD, and are also able to buy the beautiful beadwork and crafts available in the boma. One would think that this would be a very profitable business, and it could be, however (as I recently learned) the world is full of corruption and greed. For example, the manyattas lack adequate marketing. The tour drivers, who bring tourists to the manyatta, are aware of this, and therefore force the manyatta to give them 2/3 of the entrance fee so that they will continue to market their manyatta. People are MEAN!! There is so much more I could talk about, but I guess that’s what my final research discussion is for 

We have learned SO SO much, and my eyes have opened wider each day. For the first five days we walked around different areas of the Tsavo-Amboseli ecosystem interviewing local people on their perceptions and feelings on cultural manyattas and wildlife conservation. There are 8 students in my group, and we were each split into groups of 2 with a local guide. It was literally a door-to-door interview; we walked from boma to boma, stopping people in their daily activities to ask them if they would conduct a survey for us. This is the part of Kenya that I don’t want to leave – the people. I was invited inside houses, given stools to sit on while everyone else stood, given cups of delicious Kenyan chai, and best of all, was invited for a lunch of roasted meat and rice (which I was nervous to eat, but I took my chances and it was SO worth it)!! All I was doing was conducting a small interview, but these people treated me as if I was an invited guest. These little girls even made me a pinky ring out of beads :) It amazed me that people were so ready and willing to open their homes to me and tell me about their problems/opinions about our research topic. Most of the people were honest and also very interested in who we were and what we were doing. One day my local guide asked me if we did this type of interviewing in America, I laughed at him and told him if we did this in America people would call the police on us.

The next four days were spent interviewing “Key Informants,” aka people we needed specific information from. Thursday we went to the Cultural Manyattas around Amboseli to interview the inhabitants. We had a very lofty goal – 6 manyattas total, with each of us interviewing 2 inhabitants per manyatta in 5 ½ hours. This did not happen, however we did do 4 manyattas. It was a very interesting because most of the information we received was biased in some form. Side Note --> there is a TON of corruption within the manyattas themselves, aka management stealing money and not distributing the revenue equally amongst all members. The problem was that when we entered the manyattas, we were pulled aside by an official, who was obviously lying, vouching that the management was perfect. He was also the one who chose the person for our second interview, and often stood there while it was being conducted, aka we were again receiving false information. After a very busy morning, we headed to Serena Lodge outside of Amboseli National Park to interview the tourists and the lodge manager. Both were interesting, however, getting tourists were very difficult since it is evidently the “high season” for French holidays. Luckily, one of the members of my group speaks French, so we put her to work.

The next day, Friday, was catch up day since we had to complete all of that day’s interviews as well as two more bomas from Thursday. The key informants for that day were groups of Morans (young men or warriors), the Mamas and the Manyatta Leaders. One thing I have found very interesting is the ability of people to deeply effect me. Maybe I am just too naïve and want to see the good in people all the time, but after every interview I am completely involved in their situation, wanting to help in every way I can. The problem is that I later learn they are lying….so who do I believe? The Leaders were so great to talk to, intimately talking about their problems with the lack of marketing and issues with the tour drivers. However, they all agreed that their management was great, and that everyone benefited from the little money that was generated from the manyattas. Aka, they’re the good guys.

The next day was even worse, on Saturday we talked to the Chairman of Olgulului GR, the Chairman of the Board for combined manyattas, the Chair of Loitokitok district, and the Social Services Officer for Loitokitok district. They all came in, one by one, and talked about what their feelings were about manyattas, what the main problems were and how they were trying to help. However, every time a new speaker came in, he would contradict the previous speaker, implying that the first was lying and exploiting the system by receiving extra benefits. We were all so confused and dumb-struck by the entire experience. Finally, the Social services officer came in and talked about how the problems of the manyatta were the fault of the Group Ranch officials (finally some truth)!! He talked to us all about their system of corruption, and what actually needs to be done to prevent future problems. However, after he left, and he was eating lunch our Research assistant, Jackson Mwato who works for African Center for Conservation (ACC), told us that HE TOO WAS LYING!!! How in the world am I going to write a research paper on this if all my data is false, but more importantly, where have all the good people in the world gone? Everyone in my group was making fun of me since “Val’s world was turned upside down.” I don’t want to always have to be on my guard, and I would like the give all people the benefit of the doubt…is that too much to ask? Luckily, it was market day in Loitokitok so after a very stressful morning, we were able to relax, go into market and get some goodies to ease our minds.

Today is our “official” last day of key informant interviews; however, we may have one more tomorrow with the Warden of Amboseli National Park. We drove to the Ol Donyo Wuas Lodge near Chyulu Hills and spoke with the Lodge manager, Anthony Childs. He was very funny and is from the UK, but calls himself a “white Maasai” (I was also being called a white Maasai, or a white mama all week since I wore my Maasai jewelry to all my interviews haha….I was also offered 10 cows by a Moran in exchange for marriage, dad, how do you feel about that exchange?). Anthony was GREAT, his lodge is very VERY nice, aka very very expensive. It only has about 20 beds, but provides great services and amazing views. It is also an excellent eco-tourist lodge, really working in close connections with the local community and the wildlife in that region. In a few minutes we are going to have our last interview for the day with the management of a manyatta that failed. All in all, a good day :)

I love you all, and I’m sorry for being so MIA the last few weeks. I’ll tell you that it probably won’t get much better, seeing as these last two weeks will be very very busy, but I’ll try to update at least once more before I head home (I can’t believe I just typed that). Byeee!!!

1 comment: